Small Team, Big Ideas: How to Manage Multiple Projects and Decide What Deserves Your Time

Your inbox should not be your to-do list.
On a small nonprofit team, your title might be Community Programs Director. Somehow, you’re also the Event Coordinator, the Marketing Director, and the Donor Relations Manager. And every one of those roles shares the same inbox.
I see this all the time. You sit down in the morning knowing exactly what you need to get done. Then you open your email. A vendor needs an answer about setup. A donor has a question. Someone sends a quick request that turns into six more emails. By lunch, you’ve helped a lot of people move their work forward, and the thing you meant to finish is still sitting on your list.
If that sounds familiar, you’re in good company. About 70% of the U.S. nonprofits in Candid’s staffing analysis had 10 or fewer employees.
Those teams still have big goals. They’re raising money to serve more families, care for more animals, or help more people find stable housing. All of that work has to move forward, and some weeks it feels like it all has to move forward at once.
That’s when I usually find myself saying the same two things to clients. Set aside time to plan ahead and manage multiple projects in one tool, then use workflow automation to handle the steps your team repeats.
Make Time to Plan Ahead and Manage Multiple Projects With a Project Management Tool
When I encourage a team to set aside time for planning, I often hear some version of, “We can’t take a week off to plan. We have too much to do.” I get it. When you’re already behind, spending a week planning can feel like falling further behind. But that time lets you see where deadlines overlap and make decisions while you still have room to move things around. That can change how the next several weeks go across every project on your plate.
Choose one project management tool before you start planning. Monday.com, Asana, ClickUp, or another tool can work. What matters is that you can manage several projects in one place. Build the plan directly in the tool so you only have to enter the work once.
If you can, block off a week. If a full week feels out of reach, please do yourself a favor and protect at least two full days. Set an out-of-office reply and give yourself time to focus. If you’re worried about the emails that will pile up, block off your first day back to catch up.
For each project, write down what you need to accomplish and add any deadlines that can’t move. Work backward from those dates to map out what has to happen along the way. Then look at all your projects together. If two deadlines land in the same week, you can see what work needs to start earlier and who has time to take it on.
Give every task a home, an owner, and a date. An endless to-do list feels overwhelming because every item is asking for your attention at once. When the work is mapped out, you can see what’s scheduled for today, what’s coming next week, and when you’ll get to everything else.
Open your project dashboard before you open your inbox. Pick one or two of the most important tasks for that day and finish them first. Then, when you open your inbox and find 50 emails asking for your time, you already know you’ve moved your own priorities forward.
My favorite part of having everything mapped out is how much mental space it frees up. You can stop running through the whole list in your head and spend more time thinking about the bigger picture and the people your work is meant to serve.
Use Workflow Automation to Take Repetitive Work Off Your Plate
The concern I hear about automation is that it’ll take the human side out of the work. And when your organization depends on relationships with donors, vendors, and community partners, of course you care about how those interactions feel.
Think about what happens after someone makes a donation. They can get a thank-you right away, while the decision to give is still fresh. A few weeks later, you can send an update that shows what their support helped make possible. If they gave to a campaign for after-school programs, tell them what the campaign helped fund and what that means for the kids who attend. Your team can write that message once, with care, and set it up to reach donors at the right time.
You can build that sequence in donor management software or use a donation form that connects to your email platform. And if someone replies with a question about the program, a person on your team can pick up the conversation. You can even build in a reminder for someone to make a personal thank-you call.
Vendor coordination is another place where this can save hours. Think about how many emails it takes to collect each vendor’s contact information, ask about power needs, get required documents, and explain where to unload. A single form can collect those details. Submitting it can trigger a confirmation with next steps, followed by reminders about outstanding paperwork and an email with load-in instructions before the event. Then when a vendor has a trailer that won’t fit through the main entrance, you have time to work out a plan with them.
And this is where my love of organization really kicks in. Put the automation and the human follow-up in your project plan. Give someone a deadline to write and test the emails. Schedule a check for missing vendor paperwork. Assign the donor calls you want someone to make. There’s real work upfront to get it all running. Once it’s set up, routine information goes out on time, and your team can see which follow-ups need a person without scanning the inbox to figure out what’s due.
Start with two things this week.
Put a planning block on the calendar and choose one repeatable task to automate. Planning helps you see where your team’s attention is needed. Automation gives you more time to spend there.

Comments